reflectivepundit

Donald Trump and the Big-Lie Theory

By Brigitte L. Nacos

When parents tell their children to tell the truth, they may cite the proverb that lies have short legs. The lesson is that you do not get away with lies.

I thought of this, when I reread an article on Donald Trump by Marie Brenner that Vanity Fair published in 1990 and republished in 2015, right after he declared his presidential candidacy.

Brenner wrote that one of Trump’s lawyers told her, “Donald is a believer in the big-lie theory.  “If you say something again and again, people will believe you.”

Obviously, the Big-Lie theory has served Donald Trump well before and after he moved into the White House. According to the fact checkers of the Washington Post, President Trump made 16,241 “false or misleading” claims during the first three years in office. In other words, more than an average of 14 lies per day.

And, yet, with TV, radio, and online Trumpian propagandists at his service, Trump disproved the saying that lies have short legs.

During his ascent to and rule as liar-in-chief he has relentlessly attacked the mainstream media as “fake” and “enemy of the American people.”

Anyone who calls himself a “very stable genius” does not allow disagreement when he muddles fact and fiction. Thus, after the premier public health scientist Dr. Anthony Fauci corrected Trump statements during press conferences in the White House, he all but disappeared from that stage. One appearance in the last seven events.   

Dr. Deborah Birx, also a recognized public health expert, seems lately being sucked into the Trumpian circle of benevolent servants. In an appearance on “Watter’s World” last Saturday she told the FOX NEWS host that the President “looks at every bit of data” praising his “strong foundation on data” and that he is asking the right questions. When she explained Trump’s insane notion about the internal use of heat and disinfectants in the treatment of Covid-19 as his habit “to talk it through out loud” new information, she must have scored brownie points. Same, when she went after the news media.

Asked whether the media had been fair in reporting the pandemic, Dr. Birx answered forcefully,

I think the media is very slicey and dicey about how they put sentences together in order to create headlines. …I think often the reporting may be accurate in paragraph three, four, and five. But I’m not sure how many people get to paragraph three, four, and five…And I think the responsibility the press has is to really ensure that the headlines reflect science and data that is in the piece itself.”

No criticism of the Big-Lie theorist and his dismal relationship to truth and fact even during the current health emergency. Instead, an admonition of the mainstream media that records his falsities and misleading statements day-in and day-out.

This morning, President Trump threw another tweet bomb in the direction of the mainstream media.  “FAKE NEWS, THE ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE!” he wrote. “There has never been, in the history of our Country, a more vicious or hostile Lamestream Media than there is right now, even in the midst of a National Emergency, the Invisible Enemy!”

The White House then informed reporters that the previously scheduled afternoon press briefing would not be held. Another signal that these press conferences are not about informing the public about the health crisis but rather about the president’s vanities.

P.S.  A few hours after announcing that the day's press briefing was canceled the White House let it be known that the President would “brief the nation” at a news conference in the afternoon. The stable genius needs the stage and always the starring role.

Covid-19 Crisis and the Failed Presidency

By Brigitte L. Nacos

As Americans fear for their own and their family members’ physical, mental, and economic survival and look to the President and the White House to manage the existential Covid-19 crisis with competence and empathy, they do not find what they need in Donald Trump and his administration’s disaster response. The President denies any responsibility for his failure to speed up disaster preparedness when he was well aware of this new global killer virus and effective response measures when he could no longer deny the lethal threat of the virus right here in our country.

Instead of using his overlong televised press conferences to unite the polarized nation, Mr. Trump conducts them like campaign rallies full of narcissistic self-aggrandizement and bomb-throwing against reporters asking “nasty” questions and governors pleading for more federal disaster help in order to save the lives of Americans.

In the “Afterword” of the paperback edition of his book “Time to Get Tough” Trump wrote,

“A great leader can bring America together. But unfortunately for us, Barack Obama is not a leader. So who can the country turn to?”

This was published in 2015, the pre-primary time, when he obviously figured he would be the president who would bring unity to this country. Yet, in more than three years at the helm he has not united Americans. Indeed, he has magnified partisan and ideological polarization. That’s why there is no strong rally-‘round-the-president effect at the height of this deadly crisis.

In serious, national emergencies a president is not supposed to “backup” governors of the individual states as the President claimed yesterday in a repeat of similar statement. No, when disasters strike, the President is the one who must lead and become the crisis manager-in-chief.  This is the time when he has to provide consistent and factual information as well as assure and console a scared and suffering nation.

In his book “Presidential Character” James Barber argues that character, the core of personality, determines how “the President orients himself toward life-not for the moment, but enduringly." Obviously, this is not a character trait of this president. In “The Art of the Deal” Trump wrote,

“Most people are surprised by the way I work. I play it very loose. …You can’t be entrepreneurial if you’ve too much structure. I prefer to come to work each day and just see what develops”

This self-described attention to the moment—not the larger context—explains why this attention-challenged president changes his positions again and again and creates confusion. In the same book, he reveals, “I try to learn from the past, but I plan for the future by focusing exclusively on the present.” Exclusively focusing on the present--that’s the problem with this presidency and one of the major reasons for its failure.

There is no interest in the institutional memory and the professional expertise of civil servants—not even when it comes to responding to disaster. Key positions in the executive branch, and especially in agencies charged with emergency preparedness are held by political appointees without expertise in the areas they are supposed to guide. They did carry out their most important mission, namely, to reject and erase what previous presidents and their administrations left behind—including, extensive preparedness protocols for global pandemics that many scientists predicted for years.

During the 2016 Obama-Trump transition, officials from both sides got together for a pandemic table exercise that assumed the possibility or even likelihood of such a global disaster striking within the next few years.

Instead of continuing the work of the previous administration, the Global Health Security Office in the National Security Council was dismantled during John Bolton’s tenure as National Security Advisor. Although Trump claimed in one of his press events that he knew nothing about this, his underlings knew then and know now that he wants everything erased that has a link to his predecessor.

But the President and his White House crew ignored also a warning of lacking preparedness for a killer virus pandemic by their own administration.

Covid-19: Who are the Real Enemies of the American People?

By Brigitte L. Nacos

As the Covid-19 death toll moved towards 5,000 this week and U.S.  President Trump announced that a total of between 100,000 and 200,000+ Americans not surviving the pandemic would be “a win,” Trump’s favorite media stars continued to minimize the health crisis and instead blamed and attacked their usual selections of enemies of the people. As they tell it day-in and day-out, the Coronavirus is not a major problem, if any. In short form, this is their take: the fake news media hype the virus into an existential threat and the collective far left/democratic/liberal/socialist deep state exploit this hoax to realize their un-American agenda and to oust the heroic president whose early actions (closing the borders to Chinese travelers) prevented a real health crisis.

Not long ago, President Trump awarded Rush Limbaugh, the far-right talk show host, the Medal of Freedom, praising him for “decades of tireless devotion to our country.” Well, the devoted patriot Limbaugh told his listeners the other day that our economy is being destroyed under the guise of saving life.  Tell that to the families of the 5,000 victims of covid-19! Tell that to the many thousands of men and women, young and old, poor and rich on respirators fighting for their lives! Tell that to the many thousands of medical doctors, nurses, firefighters, police officers, and other emergency personnel who put their lives on the line without sufficient personal protection equipment.

Limbaugh is not the only one among President Trump’s soul mates in the media whose vitriolic rhetoric has not weakened in the face of the current crisis. Instead, they have sharpened the gap between the conservative Trumpian “us” and the unpatriotic “them” who threaten the reactionary “Make America Great Again” and “America First” agenda. It is telling that Dr. Anthony Fauci, the leading scientist on infectious diseases and advocate of strict defense measures against Covid-19, needs now beefed up security in response to death threats. For the far right, he has become the face of the “deep state” simply because he tells Americans the facts and the truth.

Every day, every hour, every minute the numbers of infected and dead Americans and people around the world grow in spite of the Covid-19 hoax conspiracy theories. The media personalities who denounced for weeks and continue to condemn the grim assessments and recommendations of leading scientists may well have influenced those Republican governors, mayors, county executives, and other decision-makers who were slow in adopting or continue to refuse social distancing measures into their respective communities.  

As for the Covid-19 deniers, it becomes clearer every day who the real enemies of the American people are!

Less clear is whether and how those prominent virus deniers in Trumpian propaganda orbit and their beloved President reconcile their unchanged Covid-19 views with the recent changes in Trump’s public positions, namely the recognition of the fast spreading virus as lethal threat and more urgent problem than the economy and the stock market.

Whatever the outcome of the contradiction between Trumpian opinion makers and their hero turns out to be, it will affect our country’s struggle against the deadly virus in our midst--and its costs in terms of lives saved and lost.